close close
Pharma and Biotech Pharma and Biotech
Menu
close
Thinking ahead today

Alternative cooling systems for the future

Inhalte auf dieser Seite
Inhalte auf dieser Seite
Thinking ahead today

Alternative cooling systems for the future

The era of synthetic refrigerants is coming to an end. Regulatory requirements are accelerating their phase-out, while demands for process safety and sustainability continue to rise. In the face of climate change, environmentally friendly technologies are a requirement.

Optima offers solutions that actively shape this transition: natural refrigerants in cascade systems, liquid nitrogen, and air-based cooling units. This ensures long-term production reliability, regulatory compliance, and a reduced carbon footprint.

OPTIMA solutions FAQ
Compliant cooling. Sustainable action.

New rules, new cooling solutions

With the revised EU F-Gas Regulation 2024 and international agreements such as the Kyoto Protocol, fluorinated refrigerants are facing increasing regulatory pressure. The clear objective: a near-complete phase-out of climate-damaging F-gases, particularly hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs).

The key factor is the GWP value – the higher the global warming potential, the sooner a ban is likely.

Comparison between US and EU F-Gasses Phase-Down
F-Gases: EU vs. USA - The revised EU phase-down plan (2024 revision) reduces F-gases significantly faster than previous regulations and current U.S. policies. This has major implications for refrigeration and freeze drying technologies.
OPTIMA solutions. Alternative cooling.
  • Cascade system with natural refrigerants
  • Air
  • Liquid Nitrogen (LN₂)
  • Cascade and Nitrogen (combination)
Next
Picture of a Cascade
Cascade system with natural refrigerants

Natural refrigerants offer negligible global warming potential and excellent thermodynamic properties. They enable compact, energy-efficient systems using standard reciprocating compressors and globally available service support. Cascade systems combine two separate circuits with different refrigerants and cool the ice condenser indirectly.

When installed in ventilated housings with gas detection systems and low refrigerant charges, only minimal explosion protection is required. Appropriate sensors and active ventilation ensure complete system safety.

MIRAI X CRYO 20 Machine
Air

As a refrigerant, air offers an environmentally friendly alternative to conventional refrigeration systems in freeze dryers. In a closed-loop system, air is cooled via the Joule-Thomson effect and used to chill silicone oil down to -80 °C and below. This technology is virtually maintenance-free, incurs low operating costs, and eliminates typical refrigerant risks such as leakage, toxicity, or flammability.

This equipment can provide the required level of refrigeration capacity without the need to connect an additional cooling source (LN2 or buffer tanks). The specific configuration is determined by the customer’s requirements, existing infrastructure, and available space.

Liquid Nitrogen (LN₂)

Liquid nitrogen is used to cool both the product shelves and the condenser. In a shell-and-tube heat exchanger, LN₂ evaporates and cools the silicone oil, which is circulated by pumps to ensure even temperature distribution across the shelves. The condenser can be cooled either directly via LN₂ evaporation or indirectly via a second silicone oil circuit.

Key advantages include compact installation, fewer components, and minimal maintenance. Cooling water is not needed, and operational energy consumption is low. Although LN₂ is a natural refrigerant that offers an environmentally friendly solution, the energy required for its production and the necessary infrastructure must be taken into account.

Pharma Building
Cascade and Nitrogen (combination)

The combination of a cascade system and liquid nitrogen unites the advantages of both technologies: the high energy efficiency and availability of the cascade with the rapid, ultra-low cooling power of LN₂. This allows load peaks to be managed, freezing times to be reduced, and maximum process reliability to be ensured. The solution is flexibly adaptable and delivers dependable cooling even under the most demanding production conditions.

OPTIMA solutions. Alternative cooling.

Cascade system with natural refrigerants
Picture of a Cascade

Natural refrigerants offer negligible global warming potential and excellent thermodynamic properties. They enable compact, energy-efficient systems using standard reciprocating compressors and globally available service support. Cascade systems combine two separate circuits with different refrigerants and cool the ice condenser indirectly.

When installed in ventilated housings with gas detection systems and low refrigerant charges, only minimal explosion protection is required. Appropriate sensors and active ventilation ensure complete system safety.

Air
MIRAI X CRYO 20 Machine

As a refrigerant, air offers an environmentally friendly alternative to conventional refrigeration systems in freeze dryers. In a closed-loop system, air is cooled via the Joule-Thomson effect and used to chill silicone oil down to -80 °C and below. This technology is virtually maintenance-free, incurs low operating costs, and eliminates typical refrigerant risks such as leakage, toxicity, or flammability.

This equipment can provide the required level of refrigeration capacity without the need to connect an additional cooling source (LN2 or buffer tanks). The specific configuration is determined by the customer’s requirements, existing infrastructure, and available space.

Liquid Nitrogen (LN₂)

Liquid nitrogen is used to cool both the product shelves and the condenser. In a shell-and-tube heat exchanger, LN₂ evaporates and cools the silicone oil, which is circulated by pumps to ensure even temperature distribution across the shelves. The condenser can be cooled either directly via LN₂ evaporation or indirectly via a second silicone oil circuit.

Key advantages include compact installation, fewer components, and minimal maintenance. Cooling water is not needed, and operational energy consumption is low. Although LN₂ is a natural refrigerant that offers an environmentally friendly solution, the energy required for its production and the necessary infrastructure must be taken into account.

Cascade and Nitrogen (combination)
Pharma Building

The combination of a cascade system and liquid nitrogen unites the advantages of both technologies: the high energy efficiency and availability of the cascade with the rapid, ultra-low cooling power of LN₂. This allows load peaks to be managed, freezing times to be reduced, and maximum process reliability to be ensured. The solution is flexibly adaptable and delivers dependable cooling even under the most demanding production conditions.

Shelves and ice condensers: Different cooling requirements

Two components, two cooling strategies

The cooling requirements of product shelves and ice condensers depend heavily on the specific recipe and loading conditions. With alternative refrigeration systems, it is often advisable to use a separate cooling circuit—or even a second system—to optimally meet the demands of both components.

Shelves
Shelves

To ensure consistently high product quality, shelves must cool pharmaceutical products quickly and precisely in a range from –40 °C to –65 °C. This requires significant cooling capacity and maximum dynamic response. A linear, precisely controlled temperature profile without fluctuations is essential.

Ice condensator
Ice condenser

The main function of the ice condenser is to achieve temperatures as low as –80 °C. Although the cooling process is less time-critical, it represents the largest share of energy consumption in the freeze drying cycle. Precise temperature control helps reduce energy loss and enhances the overall sustainability of the system.

Graph with KPIs

Energy efficiency compared:

In temperatures between –80 °C and –70 °C, the cascade system using R1270/R170 offers better energy efficiency than cold air technology. Below –70 °C, however, cold air systems achieve a higher coefficient of performance (COP). Liquid nitrogen systems (LN₂) show the lowest COP values across the entire temperature range and are therefore significantly less efficient.

Cooling technology that does more

Smart technology for safer outcomes

Digital twin Rendering

Digital twins

Digital twins enable Optima to simulate production processes in advance. Proprietary calculation tools validate the system design and determine the maximum sublimation rate for accurate component sizing.

Frequency converter

Frequency converters

Intelligent frequency converters significantly reduce the consumption of steam, water (WFI or PW), liquid nitrogen, and electricity. This lowers your operating costs and increases the sustainability of your production.

Rendering machine

Customized system

With a scientific approach and early-stage consulting, we take all framework conditions into account from the outset – from utilities to formulations – thereby minimizing risks, avoiding deviations, and ensuring a smooth process.

Machine Alternative cooling systems – Natural refrigerantsMachine Alternative cooling systems – Natural refrigerants
Cooling solutions that fit your needs

Your cooling. Our technology independence.

Optima’s experience in all common refrigeration technologies means our team can provide independent, unbiased consulting. This ensures you get the cooling solution that fits your processes, infrastructure, and system layout perfectly.

Through comprehensive comparisons of all available systems – including total cost of ownership – we offer you the most technologically advanced, economically efficient, and sustainable solution.

Mockup Preview
Alternative Refrigeration
Whitepaper

Are you looking for solutions that combine compliance and sustainability? 

Our whitepaper provides a detailed overview of modern freeze-drying and explores how alternative cooling systems are revolutionizing the industry. It highlights Optima's innovative solutions, including cascade systems with natural refrigerants, liquid nitrogen, cold air, and hybrid cascade/liquid nitrogen systems.

Blog-Highlights: Focus on alternative cooling systems

More blog posts

FAQ

  • Why do refrigerants in freeze drying systems need to be replaced?
    Due to stricter F-gas regulations and international climate agreements (Kyoto and Montreal Protocols), many commonly used refrigerants with high Global Warming Potential (GWP) are being banned or heavily restricted.
     
  • What are the advantages of natural refrigerants over F-gases?
    Natural refrigerants such as liquid nitrogen (LN2), air, propane, and ethane have very low or no GWP, are widely available, and offer long-term regulatory security.
     
  • Are there sustainable and future-proof options?
    Yes. There are three low-GWP options that are sustainable and future-proof: nitrogen, cold air, and cascade systems with natural refrigerants.
     
  • Is the use of alternative refrigerants safe?
    Yes. Optima develops explosion-protected system concepts with integrated safety monitoring and negative-pressure systems to meet the highest safety standards.
     
  • Which solution is best for our company?
    The ideal solution depends on factors such as process temperature, product characteristics, site-specific requirements (e.g., explosion protection, permits), local availability, and operational priorities.
     
  • Will operating costs increase with alternative refrigerants?
    Not necessarily. Natural refrigerants often offer favorable energy performance. For nitrogen-based systems, costs depend on local nitrogen supply. Efficiency gains can lead to cost neutrality or even savings.
     
  • Can existing systems be retrofitted for alternative refrigerants?
    Yes, retrofit solutions are possible but must be planned individually, as technical adjustments (e.g., explosion protection for propane/ethane) may be required.
     
  • What are the benefits of hybrid solutions?
    Hybrid or combination systems integrate multiple refrigerants and technologies to provide temperature range flexibility, increased redundancy, and optimized energy and process performance.

Your question hasn't been answered? Feel free to write to us.

Ask question
Jörg Rosenbaum, Jakob-Trenk
Do you have questions or would you like to discuss your specific requirements with Optima's experts?
OPTIMA pharma | Experts for lyophilization
Jörg Rosenbaum, Jakob-Trenk
OPTIMA pharma | Experts for lyophilization
+49 6462 91576 - 0 Write e-mail
© 2025 OPTIMA. All rights reserved.
loading ...